Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Beeswax's avatar

I'm relating strongly to your feeling of relief. I was shocked at how much better I feel, knowing that we won't have to endure four more years with Harris as the puppet figurehead of a regime that endorses sex-denying mutilation of minors and the erasure of women.

But I have a slightly more optimistic view of the activism of Democrat TERFs like Kara Dansky. You might be right that the Democrats will never see reason, since they're so heavily invested in trans ideology, both financially and in terms of their morally superior self-branding.

Dansky would love to see the Democratic party evolve, but in the meantime, she's a realist. She works with anyone whose views are consonant with hers, regardless of party or sex. She partners with Republican feminists, usually female athletes and their allies. These women are beasts on the issues of women's prisons and sports. Organizations like Independent Women's Network are doing tremendous work that mirrors the work on the left (with, of course, the exception of abortion).

Also, because she's an attorney with expertise in criminal justice, Dansky understands the legal ramifications of every lawsuit on the docket in the U.S. courts. She communicates with TERFS across the Pond. The other day, JK Rowling and Richard Dawkins quoted her on social media. She's not sitting around waiting for the Democrats to change, she's a change maker, through her actions and her words. Her books, The Abolition of Sex, and The Reckoning, although written to educate Democrats, speak to anybody who cares about the issue. Her reach is broad and non-partisan, and she's indefatigable.

The Democrat party may never relinquish its endorsement of trans ideology because of the financial incentives, but the tide seems to be turning, especially if Trump is well advised and doesn't make the typical Republican error of blowing up the very thing they're trying to fix. I already see a flaw in Trump's promise, which is that he wants to prevent people of any age from transitioning. This is a bridge too far and doomed to backfire, because ADULTS have the right to bodily autonomy, and this libertarian argument will resonate with members of both parties. Personal health decisions should not be legislated as long as an adult has all the facts and is in a position to understand the risks and give informed consent, with the caveat that the rights of women and children must be protected and the term "gender" is stripped of its religious privileges under the law.

It's my expectation that Dansky and others like her will never back down. Her slogan is "if we can be heard, we will win." This assumes that people are capable of listening and the message is intelligible, regardless of party affiliation. One way or the other, we will be heard and we will win.

Expand full comment
Alex Overton Overdone's avatar

Thank you for this post, Gary! I'm a lesbian living in British Columbia, a.k.a Canada's California. (Where lots of CA draft dodgers went) There was a huge Conservative surge in our recent elections for the same reasons Trump won. Normal gays, Normal lesbians, Normal parents and anyone else who wants to avoid Government control of our thoughts and words and ability to make decisions for our children without losing custody or being thrown in jail, voted out of the hope for a more sane world. I agree that it is crazy and bizarre that Trump is the choice most likely to enable a return to sanity, but that is where we are. That is the world that DEI, the reboot of middle class White-saviourism and Leftist Luxury beliefs have created. People in both Canada and the USA who are surprised by this result are clearly not paying attention. I hate all of the bullshit that is supposedly done in 'our name' to protect Queer Kids. It is abhorrent. I am glad to know you're taking time for your mental health, but also very relieved to read this post. It helps me feel less alone.

Expand full comment
41 more comments...

No posts